Pain Awareness Month: The Critical Role of Hospice Care in Managing Pain and Terminal Agitation
Pain and Terminal Illness: Pain is a prevalent symptom in terminal illnesses, with studies indicating that up to 80% of cancer patients experience pain at some point during their illness . Effective pain management is essential to improve the quality of life for these patients. Hospice care provides a comprehensive approach to pain management, utilizing a combination of pharmacological and non-pharmacological interventions tailored to individual patient needs.
Pharmacological Interventions: Hospice care employs various medications to manage pain, including opioids, non-opioids, and adjuvant analgesics. Opioids remain the cornerstone of pain management in terminal illnesses due to their efficacy. However, there is often hesitation from families regarding their use due to myths and misconceptions. It is important to communicate that when used appropriately under medical supervision, opioids can significantly enhance comfort without hastening death .
Non-Pharmacological Interventions: In addition to medications, hospice care incorporates complementary therapies such as relaxation techniques. These interventions can help alleviate pain and enhance overall well-being, providing a holistic approach to patient care.
Managing Terminal Agitation
Terminal agitation, characterized by restlessness, confusion, and anxiety, affects many patients nearing the end of life. It can be distressing for both patients and their families. Hospice care professionals are skilled in identifying and managing terminal agitation through personalized care plans that may include:
Medications: Sedatives, antipsychotics, and anxiolytics can help manage symptoms of agitation and anxiety.
Environmental Modifications: Creating a calm and soothing environment can reduce triggers of agitation.
Emotional and Spiritual Support: Providing support to address psychological and spiritual distress can significantly reduce agitation.
Reducing Hospitalizations
Frequent hospitalizations can be traumatic for terminally ill patients and their families. Hospice care focuses on providing comprehensive care at the place the patient calls home, thus minimizing the need for hospital admissions. Research has shown that patients receiving hospice care have fewer hospitalizations and emergency room visits compared to those not enrolled in hospice programs .
Addressing Myths about Pain Medications in Hospice Care
One of the barriers to hospice referrals is the misconception that pain medications, particularly opioids, are harmful or hasten death. It is crucial to educate families that:
Opioids, when used correctly, are safe and effective: They are essential for managing severe pain and improving quality of life.
Hospice care focuses on comfort, not hastening death: The goal is to ensure the patient’s comfort and dignity.
We are Here to Help
Hospice care is vital in managing pain and terminal agitation, ensuring that patients can spend their final days in comfort and with dignity. Let’s talk about your patients who can benefit from the pain and symptom management techniques that hospice can provide.
References
Portenoy, R. K., & Ahmed, E. (2018). Cancer pain syndromes. Hematology/Oncology Clinics of North America, 32(3), 371-385.
Breivik, H., Cherny, N., Collett, B., de Conno, F., Filbet, M., Foubert, A. J., … & Dow, L. (2009). Cancer-related pain: a pan-European survey of prevalence, treatment, and patient attitudes. Annals of Oncology, 20(8), 1420-1433.
Fine, P. G., & Portenoy, R. K. (2004). A clinical guide to opioid analgesia. The Journal of Pain, 5(2), 79-91.
Quill, T. E., & Abernethy, A. P. (2013). Generalist plus specialist palliative care — creating a more sustainable model. New England Journal of Medicine, 368(13), 1173-1175.
Connor, S. R., Pyenson, B., Fitch, K., Spence, C., & Iwasaki, K. (2007). Comparing hospice and nonhospice patient survival among patients who die within a three-year window. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management, 33(3), 238-246.
Gozalo, P. L., Teno, J. M., Mitchell, S. L., Skinner, J., Bynum, J., Tyler, D., & Mor, V. (2011). End-of-life transitions among nursing home residents with cognitive issues. New England Journal of Medicine, 365(13), 1212-1221.
Caregiver Stress Awareness in Hospice Care
By: Joelle Jean, FNP
Caring for a loved one who is terminally ill and on hospice is emotionally and physically taxing. In 2015, an estimated 39.8 million caregivers provided unpaid care to an adult with a disability or illness. The estimated value of the service supplied by caregivers is up to $470 billion since 2013.
Caregivers may deny help from others, perhaps out of guilt or obligation. However, 1 out of 6 caregivers reportnot being asked what they need to care for themselves. Caregivers can work up to 8.3 hours per day or 66 hours per weekduring their loved ones’ last days of life. Often, this is in addition to working a full-time job and caring for their own immediate family.
Caregivers are at risk for depression, severe fatigue, or burnout, or even health issues such as hypertension, stroke, obesity, or weight loss due to stress.
What is a caregiver?
A caregiver, also known as an informal caregiver, is an unpaid individual or group of individuals who provide care to a loved one. Caregivers can be a spouse, family members, partner, friend, neighbor, or combination of these individuals.
A caregiver assists their loved ones with activities of daily living which include:
Bathing
Dressing
Eating
Toileting
Shopping
Housekeeping
Transportation
Medical tasks such as giving medications, changing wound dressings, and managing pain
A caregiver can also play a significant role in coordinating care for their loved ones. Many are appointed power of attorney or the primary decision maker for their loved ones, managing finances, property, and most suitable medical care for the individual.
What causes caregiver stress or burnout?
There is no clear definition of caregiver stress. The Merriam-Webster dictionary defines stress as “a physical, chemical, or emotional factor that causes bodily or mental tension and may be a factor in disease causation.” Burnout can be a response to stress, defined as extreme emotional exhaustion. According to stress.org, stages of burnout are:
Enthusiasm
Stagnation
Frustration
Apathy or loss of interest
A caregiver with stress or burnout exhibits signs of feeling overloaded, overwhelmed, emotionally drained, tiredness, detachment from the person they are caring for, and a reduced sense of accomplishment.
Who is most affected by caregiver stress?
Caregiver stress affects the person or people directly caring for their loved one. Stress can also affect caregivers in different ways. For example, one caregiver may find specific tasks stressful or overwhelming while another caregiver may find the task relaxing and rewarding.
What are the signs and symptoms of caregiver stress?
Often, caregivers are not aware of their stress or feeling of burnout. Signs and symptoms of caregiver stress can be subtle or obvious. It is important to identify caregiver stress so it can be eased.
Anxiety
Anxiety is a stress response, activating the fight or flight response that happens chemically in the brain. Physically, anxiety can be described as:
Increased heart rate
Feelings of doom or hopelessness
Stomach pain and or spasms
Headache
Sweating
Heavy breathing
Feeling weak or tired
Worry
Fatigue
Caregivers suffering from stress may not realize they are fatigued. Fatigue is the body’s response to burnout and can be physical, emotional, or psychological.
Weight changes
Stress can cause weight changes and affect eating patterns. Weight change can occur when dealing with caregiver stress. Rapid weight gain or unexplained weight loss is a warning sign of caregiver stress and should be addressed appropriately.
Irritability
Caregivers may become easily annoyed or short-tempered with loved ones, family members, or friends. Feeling irritable may be a warning sign of caregiver stress.
Feelings of being overwhelmed
Feeling overwhelmed or anxious is normal. Caregivers may become overwhelmed with the amount of care needed to provide to their loved ones. Trouble concentrating, changes in sleep patterns, and changes in eating habits may occur.
Depression
Losing interest in activities can be a sign of depression due to the demanding responsibilities of caregiving. Signs of depression include:
Little interest or pleasure in doing things
Feeling down or hopeless
Change in sleep patterns
Fatigue and tiredness
Thoughts of death or suicide
Potential health risks as a result of caregiver stress
Chronic stress (or stress lasting for more than six weeks) can have lasting health problems. Caregivers exhibiting signs and symptoms of stress and burnout have a higher chance of developing health risks.
High blood pressure
Caregivers can suffer from high blood pressure due to the stress of caring for a loved one in hospice. If caregivers have already been diagnosed with high blood pressure, stress can make the disease worse. Uncontrolled high blood pressure puts caregivers at higher risk for:
Stroke
Atherosclerosis or disease of the arteries
Heart attack
Organ damage
Weakened immune system
The immune system is in place to protect the body from illness and disease. Stress can cause a weakened immune system. With a weakened immune system, caregivers can become sick or develop chronic illnesses such as:
Inflammation throughout the body
Increase in fat in the blood and body
Chronic pain
Frequent colds and infections
Short term memory loss
Studies have shown that a symptom of chronic stress is the shrinking of the brain. Shrinking of the brain causes short-term memory loss. Short term memory loss affects learning, judgement, and memory process.
Headaches and body pains
Stress can cause headaches and body pains. On a hormonal level, the increase of cortisol causes headaches even at rest. The physical nature of caring for a loved one on hospice- lifting, standing, walking, and rotating- can cause severe body pain or injury.
How to relieve or prevent caregiver stress and burnout
Self-care is imperative for caregivers caring for their loved ones in hospice. Self-care means caring for yourself, so you can improve your health to care for others.
Exercise regularly
Finding the time and the energy to exercise might sound difficult. However, even carving out 30 minutes a day has positive effects on your health. Exercising whether it is running, walking, swimming, or doing yoga will lower blood pressure, increase energy, and improve mood.
Asking and accepting help from others
Accepting help can be difficult for some caregivers. It is important to ask and accept help so that you are available for your loved one mentally and physically.
Under most insurances and Medicare, respite care is available to relieve the burden of caregiver stress. Respite care will give short term caregiver relief to those who are in need.
Eat and sleep well
Eating and sleeping well are fundamental in protecting your physical and mental health. A well-balanced meal of fruits, vegetables, and plant-based foods is important for physical and mental well-being. Adding vitamins such as a multivitamin, vitamin D, or vitamin B-12 can also help improve your mood and energy.
Having a good night’s sleep has many health benefits. Feeling well-rested and energized will only benefit you, as the caregiver, and your loved one. Improved memory, mood, and overall well-being are all benefits of quality sleep.
Seek out support groups
Support groups add immense value to caregivers who are caring for loved ones in hospice. Joining support groups reassures caregivers that they aren’t alone. Support groups:
Allow you to talk about your feelings
Help you realize others are going through the same situation
Reduces stress and depression
Teaches coping skills and ways to divert stress
Maintain personal relationships
Maintaining personal relationships is as important as joining support groups. Meeting up with friends or family members allows you to relax. It also allows you to take time for yourself and time away from your loved one.
Awareness of caregivers’ stress and burnout must be addressed and acknowledged for caregivers to feel supported and recognized for their challenging work. The hospice team and its services are a fundamental part of bringing this awareness to the forefront.
Hospice and Palliative Care: What’s the Difference?
The terms ‘hospice’ and ‘palliative’ care often get confused. Although they are similar, there are differences between these two types of care.
What is hospice care?
The focus of hospice care is on quality of life when a cure is no longer possible or when the burden of treatment outweighs the benefits. In general patients receiving hospice services have a life-expectancy of six months or less if the illness runs its usual course. Many people think hospice care is just for elderly people or cancer patients, but that is not the case. Hospice benefits people of any age, with any life-limiting illness. The goal of hospice is to provide comfort care by managing pain as well as providing emotional and spiritual support to the patient and their family.
Where is hospice care provided, and who is involved?
Hospice care can be provided anywhere the patient calls home, including nursing facilities in which they may reside. It involves an interdisciplinary team that includes:
A hospice physician (or medical director)
Nurses
Certified Nursing Assistants
Social workers
Chaplains or other spiritual support
Bereavement coordinators or counselors
Volunteers
What will the hospice team do?
The interdisciplinary hospice team will focus on things like:
Pain and symptom management
Emotional support
Providing medication, medical supplies, and equipment
Educating caregivers on how to care for the patient
Grief support
What is palliative care?
Palliative care, like hospice, focuses on quality of life. The difference is that palliative care is appropriate at any stage of a serious illness, not just at end-of-life. It’s an extra layer of support that treats the symptoms of an illness and supports the entire family. Patients who are receiving palliative care can continue to receive curative care such as chemotherapy, radiation, dialysis, and surgery.
Where is palliative care provided, and who is involved?
Patients can receive palliative care in settings such as hospitals, nursing homes, specialized clinics, and at home from a team of specially trained doctors, nurses, and other specialists. This team will work closely with the patient, their family and caregivers, and the patient’s other doctors to ensure everyone is on the same page.
What will the palliative care team do?
The palliative care team offers services such as:
Pain and symptom management
Care coordination with the patient’s current healthcare team (i.e. physician)
Assist with care plan development
Practical help with completing forms and making decisions about care
Help with advance directives
A side-by-side comparison of hospice and palliative care
The chart below can be used to help gain a better understanding of the difference between hospice and palliative care.
Having a hospice provider working as a partner with a nursing home may improve the quality of care a nursing home resident receives during end of life. Many studies have shown that having a hospice presence in nursing homes reduces hospital readmissions, improves the facility’s performance scores, and facilitates conversation between the resident and their families regarding end-of-life treatment options.
The difference between nursing homes and hospice
When a loved one’s health condition declines, the decision to transition to comfort care is not an easy one. However, before a decision is made you must know the difference between a nursing home and hospice.
Hospice care services
Hospice is an approach to care for people experiencing a life-limiting illness. It offers comprehensive services that address the physical, spiritual, social, and emotional needs and preferences of the patient and family. The hospice team includes nurses, doctors, social workers, certified nursing assistants, and chaplain and bereavement services to ensure that the patient receives medical, physical, emotional, and spiritual support in any place the patient calls home.
Nursing homes and long-term care facilities
Nursing homes and long-term facilities serve as a place where the patient lives and needs assistance with activities of daily living such as bathing, dressing, and toileting. Care is provided by trained nurses that are ready to handle the nursing and medical requirements of the residents.
Patient hospice care eligibility
For a resident to qualify for hospice care, the resident must meet the hospice eligibility requirements that have been established by the U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). Although there is not a standardized list to qualify, CMS guidelines help with determining if a resident’s condition is appropriate to receive hospice care.
Role of hospice in long-term care homes
Hospice care is provided wherever an individual resides, which includes long-term care facilities and nursing homes, and provides specific services at the end of life to residents and their families. The long-term care facility staff provides residential, custodial services to the resident, while hospice care tends to the end-of-life needs. This is what makes hospice and the long-term facility mutually beneficial to each other. Here are few examples of the role hospice plays in long-term care facilities:
Specialized skill sets. Hospice staff provide additional expertise to the long-term care facility which include quality of life and comfort during the end-of-life phase. Additionally, once the resident has passed the family is provided with grief support.
Improved resource management. The hospice team will coordinate everything related to the hospice plan of care, including medications and coordinated care for the resident that includes their primary doctor, hospice doctors, hospice aides, and hospice nurses.
Expert medical education. The hospice team provides education that focuses on the resident’s condition, symptoms, and medications.
How hospice can assist nursing home staff
The hospice team and the nursing home staff share the responsibility for the resident’s end-of-life care.
Upskilling
The nursing home’s staff has a key role in the care of residents since these professionals are often the first individuals to notice changes in the resident. It is important to educate nursing home staff on recognizing signs and symptoms of end-of-life and when to notify the proper healthcare provider. The hospice team provides education that focuses on the resident’s condition, symptoms, and medications, and how to best care for a resident’s medical needs.
Coordinating patient care
Hospice staff helps in the coordination of the resident’s care and medications needed across all their healthcare providers, hospice team, and nursing home staff. This coordination of care assures proper communication and gives the resident’s family the ability to have questions answered.
By Joelle Y. Jean, FNP
Due to its busy nature, providers in the Emergency Room (ER) may not immediately identify patients for hospice care. Approaching patients or family members about hospice can also be challenging-especially if they have specific questions. This hospice checklist can help guide providers on when they should consider a patient for hospice.
What is hospice?
Hospice is for patients who are at the end of life. Patients can have a terminal illness or declining health from a chronic illness. The hospice team can coordinate care with health care providers to manage and treat patients.
Initiating hospice early in the disease process has many benefits for the patient and family members. Hospice is there to improve the quality of life and provide comfort for patients during their end of life. Benefits of hospice include:
Improved physical and psychological symptoms
Caregiver relief
Reduced hospitalizations
Lowered hospitalization costs
Reduced hospital deaths
Barriers to initiating hospice
Studies have shown that providers initiate hospice too late- patients die within weeks of entering hospice. There are barriers that cause ER providers to wait or not consider hospice. Some barriers include:
Not having the right resources
Breakdowns in patient-clinician communication
Failing to identify terminal stage of life
Geographical and socioeconomic barriers
Head-to-toe hospice checklist
Alzheimer’s disease and dementia
Patients in the late stages of Alzheimer’s disease or dementia are candidates for hospice. At this stage, they start to lose activities of daily living (ADLs) and cannot complete basic functions on their own. These functions include:
Bathing
Dressing
Eating
Swallowing
Other signs providers should consider patients with Alzheimer’s disease or dementia for hospice are:
Loss of the ability to walk (life expectancy is about a year)
Patients in their late stages of heart failure (HF) are candidates for hospice. Providers should consider hospice if the patient has:
Visited the ER two or more times in the past six months
A decline in ADLs
Severe HF symptoms such as dyspnea, angina, fatigue
Not responded to pharmacological and non-pharmacological interventions
Ineligible for surgery
Weight and muscle loss
NYHA class three/four heart failure
Lung disease and lung cancer
Patients with end-stage lung disease and lung cancer are hospice candidates. Providers should consider hospice if the patient:
Has frequent ER visits
Increased weight loss
Increased dyspnea at rest even with oxygen
Stage four non-small lung cancer
Liver disease
Patients with end-stage liver disease are candidates for hospice. Liver disease is the 12th leading cause of death in the United States. Patients with liver disease are often overlooked for hospice care. Providers should consider hospice for patients with end-stage liver disease if they are:
Ineligible for a liver transplant
Increased pain
Increased pruritus
Increased nausea
Depression and anxiety
A decline in cognition and weight
Cancers
ER providers can opt for hospice for patients with cancer if treatment is no longer working or there are no other treatment plans. Patients also at the end stage of their cancer can benefit from entering hospice early. Other signs a patient is ready for hospice are if the patient:
Has increased weakness
Significant weight loss
Pain control
In bed for most of the day
Sepsis
It’s not always easy to identify patients with sepsis who qualify for hospice. However, some patients meet the criteria. Providers should consider patients with sepsis for hospice if the patient:
Has impaired kidney failure
Not responding to pharmacological treatment
Require mechanical ventilation
Injury to the liver
Hyperlactemia
Hospice is available to patients who are at the end of their life. They can entire at any stage in their disease process. Initiating hospice early benefits the patient. Studies have shown that hospice improves mood, decreases medical interventions, and enhances the patient’s overall quality of life.